[cover]

Safety Practices, Firm Culture, and Workplace Injuries

Richard J. Butler, Brigham Young University
Yong-Seung Park, Kyung Hee University

Introductory chapter | Table of Contents

In 2001, there were approximately 3.7 fatal workplace injuries per 100,000 workers (including 9/11), workers made 2.1 million trips to the emergency room, and workers’ compensation insurance cost employers $63.9 billion. In addition, the indirect costs of workplace accidents—lost wages, equipment damage, and training and rehabilitation—were several times this amount. Despite the fact that human resource management (HRM) practices can directly affect the severity and costs of such accidents, HRM is usually seen as an auxiliary function that contributes nothing to a firm’s output.

Richard J. Butler and Yong-Seung Park hope to draw attention to this oversight by presenting analysis of the impact of various HRM practices on firms’ workers’ compensation costs; specifically, which practices lower firms’ workers’ compensation costs and whether the impact is the result of changes in technical efficiency or comes through induced changes in workers’ behavior.

The authors divide HRM practices into two groups: 1) practices that a firm can unilaterally adopt that do not necessarily involve the workers in either the financial or the strategic management of the firm, and 2) practices that increase workers’ involvement in the firm in one or both of these dimensions. The first group of practices includes the degree of management involvement with the safety efforts of the firm and the level of information sharing by management. The second group includes the number of programs that allow employees to participate in the financial returns of the company, the number of programs that allow employees to participate in their firms’ strategic planning, and the intensity of employees’ involvement in this strategic planning.

Traditional models of firm behavior ignore such HRM practices, assuming management simply chooses labor and capital to maximize firms’ profits. Management is also assumed to know everything that workers know about their own behavior and about their firms’ technology. But, as Butler and Park point out, this is not realistic. Asymmetric information, where, for example, employees have knowledge that is difficult or costly for management to obtain, is common. Therefore, the authors develop a new model of safety outcomes that incorporates HRM practices. They estimate this model using data on an important outcome -- safety costs. Their results show that HRM practices do affect employees' injury claims, may help reduce injury claim frequency, and can reduce injury-claim severity. Furthermore, they weigh in on the question of whether these results occur because HRM practices are improving technical efficiency or because HRM practices are reducing disability benefits consumption associated with asymmetric information.

Butler and Park conclude with a set of policy implications for firms, workers, and workers’ compensation policy.

Related titles
  • Workplace Injuries and Diseases: Prevention and Compensation - Essays in Honor of Terry Thomason, Karen Roberts, John F. Burton Jr., and Matthew M. Bodah, Editors
  • Adequacy of Earnings Replacement in Workers' Compensation Programs, H. Allan Hunt, Editor
  • Workers' Compensation: Benefits, Costs, and Safety under Alternative Insurance Arrangements, Terry Thomason, Timothy P. Schmidle, and John F. Burton Jr.
  • Growth in Disability Benefits: Explanations and Policy Implications, Kalman Rupp and David C. Stapleton, Editors
  • Ensuring Health and Income Security for an Aging Workforce, Peter P. Budetti, Richard V. Burkhauser, Janice M. Gregory, and H. Allan Hunt, Editors
  • Disability, Work and Cash Benefits, Jerry L. Mashaw, Virginia Reno, Richard V. Burkhauser, and Monroe Berkowitz, Editors
  • Permanent Disability Benefits in Workers' Compensation, Monroe Berkowitz and John F. Burton, Jr.
  • Causes of Litigation in Workers' Compensation Insurance, Evangelos M. Falaris, Charles R. Link, and Michael E. Staten
  • SeeTechnical Reports for more on workers' compensation insurance and disability issues from the Upjohn Institute.
    Also visit our Disability and Workers' Compensation Research Hub.
  • 105 pp. 2005.
    $40 cloth ISBN 0-88099-277-8 / ISBN-13 978-0-88099-277-8
    $15 paper ISBN 0-88099-275-1 / ISBN-13 978-0-88099-275-6


    Shopping Cart Operations

    For MasterCard/Visa holders, accumulate titles in the Shopping Cart and submit your order electronically.

    Shopping Cart Operations


    Customer Service - for phone, fax or mail orders, if you have any questions, or if you'd like to download our order form.
    Alphabetical List of Books   |   Publications   |   Home Page