Career
Development
System
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
for
the Workforce Development Board of
Kalamazoo & St. Joseph Counties
and
the Kalamazoo - St. Joseph
Michigan Works! Agency
June 30, 2001
This material was developed with the support of grant funds awarded by
The Michigan Department of Career Development.
INTRODUCTION
To help place the contents of the Career Development System Comprehensive Plan in context, the following is offered as background.
The Michigan Department of Career Development (MDCD) has conceptualized Michigan’s Career Development System as having 3 subsystems:
Each Michigan Works! Area (MWA) has several governing bodies, agencies and institutions involved in establishing and delivering an array of programs and services that make up the 3 subsystems listed above. It is postulated by the MDCD that through strengthened partnerships among the organizations involved in each MWA, coordination of career development services will be enhanced, allocation of available resources will be optimized and career development system outcomes will be improved.
In an effort to move this notion forward, the MDCD has asked each of the State’s 25 Workforce Development Boards and their respective Michigan Works! Agencies to work through an extensive community-based strategic planning process involving the Career Development System partners. The thrust of this effort is "Building Strategic Partnerships for Career Development."
MISSION STATEMENT
The MISSION is a broad statement of the unique purpose for which the organization exists and the major function it performs.
The mission of the Kalamazoo - St. Joseph Michigan Works! Area is to develop, sustain, and continually improve a Career Development System that produces workforce members who possess the skills essential to participating in gainful employment and enhancing the region’s economy.
VISION
The VISION is a broad statement of what the organization foresees as beneficial changes to be realized by a predicted date.
By 2004, the vision of the Kalamazoo-St. Joseph Michigan Works! Area is to:
Attract, high tech, high pay jobs and to have workers with the skills to fill them
Meet the unfilled demand for workers in positions that are not high skill, high pay with sufficient wages to attract and keep employees
Foster increased coordination between the employer and education communities to prepare future and incumbent workers to find and maintain self-sustaining and meaningful employment
Have all current partners across the Career Development, Workforce Development, and Worker Enhancement Systems view the strategic plan as their own
Work to involve the economic development and employer members of the community in future strategic planning efforts
Maintain and improve the area’s reputation as a good place to live, work, and raise a family
ASSUMPTIONS
ORGANIZATIONAL ASSUMPTIONS convey the major premises and suppositions that drive the nature of the organization’s decision-making and practices.
SIGNIFICANT TRENDS & CRITICAL ISSUES
(
from the environmental scan)
CRITICAL TRENDS AND ISSUES are those internal and external factors that must be dealt with if the organization is to proceed in a manner consistent with its mission.
Industry employment forecasts indicate employment totals (wages and salaries) in the period from 1996 – 2006 are expected to increase by 10.34% across the state. In the Kalamazoo/St. Joseph Michigan Works! Area, the increase is expected to be 7.20%. Forecasts also indicate the almost 28% (2,240) of the total number of manufacturing jobs Michigan will lose (8100) will be from the Kalamazoo/St. Joseph Michigan Works Area.)
While the four nearby counties showed an average growth rate in per capita income of 19.87% in the period from 1994-1998, the Kalamazoo/St. Joseph MWA had an increase of 15.54% for the same time period. Included in the comparison are Ottawa, Kent, Calhoun, and Muskegon Counties.
From 1990-1997, Kalamazoo County experienced a net loss of 3,403 persons and a net loss of $133,823,000 in income. In the same period, St. Joseph County gained 201 persons but lost $2,292,000 in income.
When asked the open-ended question: "Currently what are the major problems facing your firm?" Nearly 40% complained about the tight labor market. It isn’t that employers cannot find qualified workers but that they cannot find workers at the wage levels they are able or willing to afford."
These include attendance, positive attitude, responsibility, common sense, initiative, problem solving, flexibility, and punctuality.
In the past 5 school years beginning with 95/96 and ending with 99/00, area scores have met or exceeded state results in at least 50% of the areas compared with the exception of the 99/00 school year when only 25% of areas tested were better than the state. It is too soon to tell if this is a gap that will widen
h) Although slightly less than State averages, persistent and significant poverty levels continue to exist in the Area.
It should be noted that while the content of this plan constitutes products of the strategic planning process to date, establishing and strengthening strategic partnerships is viewed as an on-going effort in the Kalamazoo - St. Joseph Michigan Works! Area.
STRATEGIC DIRECTION
STRATEGIC DIRECTION, established by a well-crafted strategic plan, sets the course for the organization’s capacity to thrive in its rationally anticipated future.
In the skills-intensive economy of the 21st Century, one thing is clear: knowing means growing. Indeed, the correlation between education attainment and income is becoming stronger and stronger. It has been difficult in the past and it will be virtually impossible in the future for individuals with low levels of education and underdeveloped workplace skills to vigorously participate in the ever-changing economy.
The improvement of education levels and workplace skills will become an increasingly critical force for propelling the local economy into a growth pattern equal to or better than neighboring economies. Optimized learning at all levels and for all populations holds the promise of moving families out of poverty, improving per capita income, enhancing the local economy, and bettering the over-all quality of life for the region’s residents.
Learning improvement, skills enhancement, and vigorous employment for those participating in the Career Development System’s education and training activities are the prevailing themes in this plan. The Kalamazoo-St. Joseph Career Development System offers the following goals and strategies as products of its community-based strategic planning process: (1/2001)
STRATEGIC GOALS
STRATEGIC GOALS are statements defining the desired, measurable outcomes resulting from the organization's efforts.
By 2004
Goal 1. Enhance workplace readiness skills.
Improve Work Keys scores of the number of high school and community college students and /or incumbent workers taking the Work Keys assessment by an average of at least one level on 3 assessments (e.g. Reading, Applied Mathematics and Locating Information; average one level gain per assessment
Goal 2: Improve employment and income circumstances for Workforce Development Program participants.
Increase average hourly wage at placement of Workforce Development Program from, $7.50 to $7.75 in year 1, $8.00 in year 2, and $8.50 in year 3.
Goal 3: Strengthen incumbent worker skills.
Increase number* of employed workers completing community college classes in technical areas by 5% each year. * Data on actual numbers is currently not available.
LONG-TERM STRATEGIES
STRATEGIES are significant, multi-year, general efforts toward which the organization (is or) will be dedicating resources in order to achieve its strategic goals.
Addressing Goal 1: Enhanced Workplace Readiness Skills
Addressing Goal 2: Improved Employment and Income Circumstances for Workforce Development Program Participants
Addressing Goal 3: Strengthened Incumbent Worker Skills
STRATEGIC ASSETS & INITIATIVES
Strategy #1 to achieve Goal #1: Assessing workplace readiness
ASSETS
At the Kalamazoo Valley Community College M-TEC Testing Center, 48 people were assessed in the first four months of the Center’s operation. Expectations are to increase this number by 10% and to complete a minimum of six profiles in the coming year. A minimum increase in the number of assessments and completed profiles of 5% per year in subsequent years is planned.
ASSETS continued for Strategy #1
The Testing Center at Glen Oaks Community College in Centreville is on its way to becoming fully operational. Four assessments have been completed. In the 2001-2002 school year, all ninth graders will be tested as part of their career awareness. The expectation is to complete a minimum of four profiles by June 30, 2002. A 5% increase in the number of assessments and profiles in each subsequent year is planned.
INITIATIVES
Increase the number of workplace readiness skills assessments by 10% over the previous year. (48 were completed from January- June 2001.)
Increase employer awareness of the benefits of Work Keys job profiling and testing. Measure by an increase of 5% per year in the number of profiles requested. (No profiles were completed thus far in the year 2001.)
Introduce Work Keys testing in all adult education programs for those students who cite job placement or retention as a primary goal. Measure by an increase of 5% per year in the number of assessments completed. (Work Keys testing in adult education has not started as of the date of this summary.)
Strategy #2 to achieve Goal #1: Influencing workplace readiness skills
ASSETS
Of the 30 technical programs available at Glen Oaks Community College, all have a placement rate in excess of 92.98%. The Health Careers area (Practical Nursing Certificates and Associates degrees in Applied Nursing) had a placement rate of 100% of those who responded to the college’s survey. Detailed information regarding all 30 specific program enrollments and placement rates is not currently available. The goal is to track and record
ASSETS continued for Strategy #2
completions and employment and wage outcomes and to increase each by 3% per year through 2004.
Of the 24 technical programs available at Kalamazoo Valley Community College, all
have placement rates of at least 50%. Fifteen of the 24 have placement rates of 100%. The largest of these include: Cardio-Respiratory Care Practitioner, Computer Information Systems, Law Enforcement, and Medical Assistant Technology. Detailed information regarding all 24 programs is not currently available. The goal is to track and record the completions, employment and wage outcomes and to increase each by 3% per year through 2004.
Career Day at KVCC - Career/occupational information for 3000 8th graders from Kalamazoo County public and private middle schools. 30 occupational careers in six career pathways are presented. Students can experience three pathways of their choice. The goal is to continue to provide this exposure to careers with an increase of 3% per year of the total 8th grade enrollments through 2004.
Focus on Freshman Program - An array of learning activities designed to assist 9th graders gain focus for success in high school. A critical "threshold" for students and parents, this program involves the initial decision-making and charting of the student’s high school instruction. The program is offered in seven of the nine districts within the Kalamazoo Regional Educational Service area. Two school districts have designed and will implement a sophomore year version to begin in the 2001-2002 school year. The goal is to increase the number of participating school districts by one district per year until all are using the program.
Career Pathways Program - a major effort in career exploration, self-assessment, decision-making, pathway-of-interest selection, and planning for 10th grade students; includes a component for aligning secondary general education curriculum with six career pathways thus increasing connections between the classroom and the world of work. All nine school districts will be applying for a Career Pathways grant. Two of the nine school districts are not yet operational but are developing their curricula. The goal is to increase the number of participating school districts by one district per year until all are using the program.
ASSETS continued for Strategy #2
Career/Technical Education Programs (called Education for Employment in the Kalamazoo area)
Thirty different programs with a total enrollment of 3359 students provide courses for 11th and 12th grade students in school-site settings for 18 occupational clusters. Worksite settings cover 8 occupational areas. 60% of all 11th and 12th grade students are served. New programs initiated in 2000-2001 are Computer Technology/Network Administration and two Allied Health programs. Business services technology programs are offered in all nine school districts. In 2000-2001, 214 Education for Employment students were enrolled in co-op or apprenticeship programs. The long-range plan is to develop an approach for the 9th and 10th grade students who do not enroll in the Education for Employment programs. Many are "at risk" students. Education for Employment plans to continue with a goal of increasing participation in Education for Employment by 3% of 11th and 12th grade enrollments through 2004. A further goal is to develop an approach for the 9th and 10th grade students who do not enroll in the program and are considered "at risk" students by the fall of 2002.
"Pathfinder" Website - Designed to connect students, educators, employers, and parents with career cluster/pathway information and Internet links to assist in career decision-making and educational planning. Currently, 672 employers are registered on the site with a list of 925 learning opportunities for students. Examples are job shadowing, apprenticeships, tours, and other options. Efforts are underway to expand the number of participating employers by 2% per year through 2004.
ASSETS continued for Strategy #2
"Career Start" Program - Career Education workbooks and curriculum activities in all K-6 classrooms allow children to learn what opportunities are available for them and to become prepared for the Career Prep activities they will encounter in grades 7-12. It is expected that the number of students participating will increase proportionate to enrollments. In 2000-2001, 1,100 workbook units were completed. The long-range plan is to have all K-6 students in St. Joseph County using the Career Start program. The number currently participating is not available.
"Career Prep" Program - Career Education workbooks and curriculum activities for all students in grades 7-12 Students create a portfolio representing their skills, abilities, achievements, interests, and career plans. Students who have been actively involved in the Career Prep process and who enter the workforce immediately after high school are able to attain higher skill, higher pay jobs. In the 2000-2001 school year, approximately 4528 workbook units were completed; an increase of 3% per year of the total enrollments is planned through 2004. Career Pathways Program - a major effort in career exploration, self-assessment, decision-making, pathway-of-interest selection, and planning for 10th grade students; includes a component for aligning secondary general education curriculum with 6 "career pathways" thus increasing connections between the classroom and the world of work. Students leave school better prepared to enter the world of work and/or higher education and are more likely to be satisfied with their job choice. An increase of 3% per year of the total enrollments is expected through 2004.
INITIATIVES
INITIATIVES
continued for Strategy 2
The Career Pathways program is expanding by developing a "Career Pathways’ Culture" and an infrastructure in each school district. All K-12 schools will be able to provide opportunities for students to participate in age-appropriate, authentic career experiences. The Pathways program is developing strategies to inform parents of multiple career pathways for their children and is also developing partnerships with secondary and post-secondary institutions to expand Career Prep programs. The goal is to increase student participation by 3% per year of total enrollments through 2004.
Refine and expand CTE programming
The curriculum of the Career and Technical Education (CTE) program is being upgraded to incorporate the application and operation of industry specific technology. The CTE staff has a range of flexible professional development and technical assistance options. Annual evaluations are completed for each CTE program using specific standards of quality. Parents and students are learning about direct credit and articulation agreements. The goal is to track the enrollment and outcomes of students involved in a direct credit or articulation agreement and increase the number by 3% per year through 2004.
Refine and expand Technical/Occupational programming by offering new health career programs in Emergency Medical Services, Medical Assisting, and Health Insurance Coder/Biller to meet the needs of local employers. The goal is to track enrollments, completions, and employment and wage outcomes and to increase the number of enrollments by 3% per year.
STRATEGIC ASSETS & INITIATIVES
Strategy #3 to achieve Goal #2: Intensifying job placement services
ASSETS
JTPA and WIA Funding
Work First Program - Welfare to Work services to assist welfare recipients in entering the job market and becoming self-sufficientFrom 1994-1999, allocations increased by 9.2% (inflation-adjusted.) The number who entered employment increased by 95% and the average wage at 90-day follow-up increased by 19.7% from $5.74 to $6.87.
WIA Youth Program - Job placement services to assist youth facing serious barriers to employmentFrom 1994-1999, allocations decreased by 66.3% (inflation-adjusted.) The number who entered employment increased by 13.9%
WIA Dislocated Workers Program - Assists laid off adults with job seeking and placement effortsFrom 1994-1999, allocations decreased by 38.1% (inflation-adjusted.) The number who entered employment increased by 13.1% and the average wage at 90-day follow-up increased by 10% from $10.48 to $11.53.
The goal for all federal and state-funded programs is to increase entered employment outcomes and average hourly wages by 3% per year through 2004.
INITIATIVES
INITIATIVES continued for Strategy 3
A unique program called "Breaking the Barriers" is a client-centered model that combines evaluation, education, training, and placement in a more individualized, intensive program. Work First participants take part in a 10- week paid work experience designed to provide longer-term employment readiness and placement services.
Since October 2000, 58 clients have been enrolled. 57 of the 58 have been employed during or after the program. 27 of the 58 are employed but in jobs without the required 20 or 30 hours (determined by family status). 30 of the 58 are in non-temporary jobs. 9 of the 30 have met the 90-days on the job requirement. 12 of the 30 have had their public assistance cash cases closed due to achieving an income that no longer warrants assistance. 12 of the 30 were terminated from the program for non-compliance or medical reasons
Given the barriers which include multiple sequences of Work First referrals, long-term welfare dependence, lack of education (very few have completed high school), disability-related issues which do not qualify for Social Security Income or Social Security Disability Income, mental health issues, substance abuse problems, average academic skills in the 5th-8th grade range, and limited problem-solving abilities, it is not surprising that just 12 of the 58 had their cases closed due to income. On the plus side, some participants are working longer and earning more than ever before in their lives. They are in the Breaking the Barriers program for transitional employment and have made notable progress.
For the coming year, the enrollment goal is 125, up from 75, pending Work First funding. Other goals are an increase of 3% in the number of participants obtaining higher wage jobs and improving self-sufficiency. An additional goal is to increase retention resources. A mentoring coordinator, a job development coordinator, and longer paid work experiences are planned.
A new collaboration called "Making It Work" is comprised of the Michigan Works! Agency, Goodwill Industries of Southwest Michigan, Work First, Kalamazoo Regional Educational Services Agency, and Housing Resources, Inc. This new retention program, "Making It Work" will provide rent subsidies for one year for Welfare to Work participants. A goal of a 3% increase in the number (75) of welfare case closures is the goal.
STRATEGIC ASSETS & INITIATIVES
Strategy #4: Expanding customized training
ASSETS
In the period from 1995-1999, funds totaling $1,382,104 (inflation-adjusted) were used to serve 37 companies and 4191 workers.
Since September 1999, 3105 people have had customized training (funded via fee for service paid by the employer or state-funded Economic Development Job Training (EDJT) grants. 303 people paid their own way to public seminar training sessions. Public seminars included topics related to the flowing industries: auto, residential construction, plumbing, electrical, and information technology. Customized training served the following manufacturing industries: automotive, medical, paper, plastics, and others whose products span several industries.
Employer-driven training programs - Job training and skill upgrading for incumbent workers funded by EDJT grants and other resources.
The Glen Oaks Center for Business Services experienced a total enrollment of 1,209 from July 1, 2000 – May 31, 2001. 612 of the total number were enrollments that resulted from "employer-driven" training funded by EDJT grants or employer payment.
Incumbent workers have been served by a combination of EDJT grants, public short-term business and computer seminars, and customized training. Two major companies benefited from training through the EDJT grants.
INITIATIVES
Expand employer-driven training through GOCC-initiated countywide business/industry "CEO Roundtable"
Four EDJT grants are pending approval. If funded, projected enrollments are estimated at approximately 1000 workers for the 2002-2003 year. The goal is to increase the number of incumbent workers participating in training by 3% (of 1209) through 2004 dependent on funding availability.
STRATEGIC ASSETS & INITIATIVES
Strategy #5: Augmenting supportive services
ASSETS
The Learning Center (tutoring services) had 12,006 student contacts in 99/00. As of May 31 2001, 122,257 contacts have been recorded. (Non-duplicated counts are not tracked.)
Other supportive services include the Women’s Center and a Student Success Team, which tackles special projects. In the Winter 2001 semester, a "pro-active intervention" pilot program was begun. The program identified students who were doing poorly at intervals during the semester and offered assistance. Preliminary data show that the intervened sections had significantly fewer students drop or fail and significantly more students earn higher grades than the sections that did not receive the intervention. The data is still be compiled and analyzed. The pilot program will be continued in the fall and winter semesters of 2001-2002. The goal is to track and record retention findings from the pilot program and if it is deemed worthy of continuation, to increase retention by 3% of the total participants (non-duplicated numbers) per year. Student participation numbers are not currently available.
INITIATIVES
NOTE: Efforts to build and invigorate strategic partnerships for career development will continue to go forward after this document’s date of submission (6/30/01)
Prepared by the staff at the W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research/Michigan Works! Agency
Contact Jan Smith at (616) 349-1533 or
smith@we.upjohninst.org with comments or questions.